NYC Insurance Recruiters
Hiring experienced insurance professionals in New York City and the surrounding region requires more than filling open roles. It demands a strong understanding of underwriting practices, claims management, regulatory compliance, risk assessment, and client service models. Goodwin Recruiting delivers this expertise to organizations across the metropolitan area. Our NYC insurance recruiters combine local market insight with a nationwide network of proven insurance talent. This allows employers to connect with qualified professionals across underwriting, claims, brokerage, risk management, actuarial support, and insurance leadership roles.
New York City’s insurance landscape continues to evolve, supported by industries such as commercial insurance, employee benefits, personal lines, reinsurance, financial services, healthcare, real estate, construction, and professional services. As risk profiles grow more complex and regulatory oversight increases, organizations need insurance professionals who can manage exposure, ensure compliance, and deliver trusted guidance to clients. Goodwin Recruiting partners with companies throughout New York City, Long Island, Westchester, Northern New Jersey, and Connecticut to build high-performing insurance teams that support long-term client relationships and sustainable business growth.
Let us help you find the right insurance professionals for your organization ⟶
Become A Client / Request Talent
"*" indicates required fields
Job seeker?
[Check out our open positions here]
Proven Insurance Recruitment in New York City
Your organization depends on insurance professionals who are analytical, detail oriented, and capable of delivering reliable risk and coverage solutions. By partnering with New York City insurance recruitment experts, you gain access to a broad pool of qualified candidates and a focused hiring process designed to deliver both immediate contribution and long-term value.
Your advantages include:
✓ Comprehensive insurance recruiting:
Hire for roles such as commercial and personal lines underwriters, claims adjusters, claims managers, insurance brokers, account executives, account managers, producers, risk managers, loss control specialists, benefits consultants, and insurance leadership roles.
✓ Efficient and dependable hiring support:
Reduce time to hire through a streamlined recruitment process that prioritizes licensing, regulatory knowledge, industry specialization, and cultural alignment.
✓ Client-focused talent placements:
Connect with insurance professionals who bring strong analytical skills, communication ability, and service orientation to support client retention, coverage accuracy, and risk mitigation.
✓ Permanent placements for long-term stability:
Strengthen your organization with full-time insurance professionals who support client continuity, regulatory compliance, and sustainable revenue growth.
Why Partner with our NYC Insurance Recruiters?
Our insurance recruiters in NYC understand the precision, confidentiality, and accountability required in today’s insurance environment. We help organizations throughout the Tri-State region build teams that meet regulatory standards, manage risk effectively, and deliver high-quality client service.
- Recruiters with real-world insurance and risk management experience:
- Many of our recruiters have backgrounds in insurance brokerage, underwriting, claims, risk management, or insurance leadership. This enables them to accurately assess technical expertise, licensing requirements, and client-facing capability.
- Local market insight supported by national reach:
- Access insurance talent throughout Manhattan, Brooklyn, Queens, the Bronx, Staten Island, Long Island, Westchester County, Northern New Jersey, and Southern Connecticut, supported by a nationwide network of experienced insurance professionals.
- A commitment to quality, accuracy, and professionalism:
- Every search is conducted with confidentiality, care, and a strong focus on aligning the right insurance talent with your organization’s market focus, regulatory obligations, and service standards.
- A long-term approach to insurance excellence:
- We help organizations secure insurance professionals who value integrity, accountability, client advocacy, and continuous improvement, ensuring success in New York City’s complex and evolving insurance marketplace.
Roles Filled by our Insurance Recruiters in New York City
- Underwriters
- Claims Adjusters
- Insurance Brokers
- Actuaries
- Claims Examiners
- Insurance Sales Agents
- Agents
- Claims Investigators
- Appraisers
- Captive Agents
- Customer Service Representatives
- Independent Insurance Agents
- Insurance Coordinators
- Loss Control Consultants
- Risk Managers
- and More!
