Columbus Insurance Recruiters

The Right Talent: Columbus Insurance Recruiters

You already know how complex and competitive the insurance industry is, especially here in Columbus. From major carriers in downtown HQs to independent agencies across Dublin, Worthington, and Westerville, there’s nonstop demand for professionals who know how to protect risk, drive growth, and build trust. As Columbus insurance recruiters, we understand just how much the right hire can impact retention, compliance, client satisfaction, and revenue.

If you're leading a team in the insurance space, you don’t need just another license-holder. You need people who bring professionalism, product knowledge, and a service-first mindset to every policy and every client.

Ready to build a team that clients trust and competitors envy? We’re ready when you are.

Find Talent

Search Jobs

Become A Client / Request Talent

"*" indicates required fields

First Name*

Last Name*

Company Email*

Phone*

Hiring Company*

State

How Did You Hear About Us?

What positions are you trying to fill?

Phone

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Job seeker?
[Check out our open positions here]

Columbus Insurace Recruiters: Specialized Recruitment

Whether you’re hiring a seasoned underwriter, a top-performing producer, or a claims specialist with compassion and precision, our Columbus insurance recruiters connect you with people who lead with integrity and perform with consistency.

We’ve partnered with agencies, brokerages, and carriers across P&C, life, health, benefits, and commercial lines. And the one thing they all know? There’s no room for turnover in a relationship-driven industry.

Here’s How Goodwin Recruiting Can Help:

✔ From Agents to Analysts to Executives
Whether you need a client-facing advisor, a policy expert, or a compliance-savvy leader, we’ll find professionals who bring both the credentials and the character.

✔ Flexible Hiring That Matches Your Business Cycles
Need someone before renewal season? Building out a new book of business? We move fast when it matters and strategically when it counts.

✔ Industry Expertise That Speaks the Language
We know the acronyms (P&C, E&O, L&H, CMS, CRM) and we know how to assess candidates beyond the resume.

✔ People Who Earn Loyalty
We focus on long-term fit, helping you find team members who clients trust, coworkers respect, and leadership relies on.

✔ Leaders Who Build Culture and Compliance
Because in insurance, success isn’t just about sales - it’s about ethics, process, and people-first performance.

Find Talent

Search Jobs

Why partner with our Columbus Insurance Recruiters?

We Scale with Your Book of Business

Opening a new office? Growing into new markets or verticals? We match your momentum with scalable talent solutions.

We Get It Right the First Time

We don’t just fill roles—we find the right fit, fast. Every candidate is vetted for experience, licenses, and alignment with your business goals.

We Know Columbus

Our local market knowledge and national reach give you access to the top talent—wherever they are, and wherever you need them.

We’ve Walked the Walk

Our recruiters have hands-on experience in the insurance world, which means we know how to identify people who don’t just “get it”—they live it.

Let’s build a team that doesn’t just sell policies, but strengthens your reputation, expands your reach, and supports your clients at every turn. Let’s get to work.

Find Talent

Search Jobs