Commercial Insurance Product Manager

Recruiting Partner: Warren Mead

Woodcliff Lake, New Jersey | Sales | Not Remote | $120,000 to $160,000 | Job ID: 183788

Job Summary

To Apply for this Job Click Here

Our client, a well-established insurance agency and surety business, is seeking a commercial lines product manager to lead the development and expansion of their small commercial insurance portfolio. The ideal candidate combines strong underwriting expertise with a producer mindset. You understand how to structure, package, and position products to win in the market while maintaining underwriting discipline.

Commercial Insurance Product Manager

Small Commercial Insurance | Product Development & Innovation

Location: Woodcliff Lake, NJ

Employment Type: Full-Time

Industry: Property & Casualty Insurance

About the Opportunity

Our client is an established, financially stable national insurance carrier experiencing significant growth and expanding its small commercial insurance platform.

We are seeking an experienced Commercial Insurance Product Manager to lead the design, development, and enhancement of small commercial insurance products, with a particular emphasis on creating innovative bundled and packaged coverage solutions.

This is a hands-on opportunity for an insurance professional who combines strong technical underwriting knowledge with product development experience and a commercial mindset. The ideal candidate understands not only how insurance products are structured and underwritten, but also how they are positioned, marketed, and sold.

You will work closely with senior leadership, underwriting, sales, and distribution partners to identify market opportunities, develop competitive products, and bring new offerings to market.

Key Responsibilities

Product Strategy, Design & Development

  • Lead the development, design, and enhancement of small commercial insurance products, including:
    • General Liability (GL)
    • Professional Liability (PL)
    • Businessowners Policies (BOP)
    • Fiduciary Liability
    • Cyber Liability
    • Employment Practices Liability Insurance (EPLI)
    • Directors & Officers (D&O) / Management Liability
    • Commercial Crime
    • Commercial Surety Bonds
    • ERISA Fidelity Bonds
  • Develop innovative bundled and packaged insurance solutions that combine multiple coverages to address the needs of specific business segments.
  • Identify underserved markets and opportunities to introduce differentiated insurance products.
  • Develop scalable product offerings that balance market demand, underwriting discipline, and profitability.
  • Establish product appetite, coverage structures, underwriting guidelines, and market positioning.
  • Work with internal teams to bring products from initial concept through successful launch.

Product Bundling & Market Development

  • Create packaged insurance solutions designed to simplify coverage purchases and provide greater value to small commercial customers.
  • Identify complementary coverages and opportunities to incorporate bonds into bundled offerings.
  • Collaborate with producers, agents, brokers, and program administrators to support product adoption and distribution.
  • Provide guidance and product expertise to internal sales teams, helping them effectively market new and existing bundled products.
  • Gather market feedback and identify opportunities to improve product competitiveness and customer retention.

Portfolio Management & Performance

  • Monitor product performance, including premium growth, loss ratios, business mix, and profitability.
  • Evaluate market trends, competitive offerings, and underwriting results to identify opportunities for improvement.
  • Recommend product enhancements, coverage adjustments, and pricing or underwriting changes as appropriate.
  • Continuously refine product offerings based on performance data, distribution feedback, and changing market conditions.

Cross-Functional Collaboration

  • Work directly with senior leadership to help establish and execute commercial insurance product strategy.
  • Collaborate with underwriting, sales, operations, and technology teams throughout product development and implementation.
  • Serve as a technical resource for internal producers and distribution partners.
  • Engage with agents, brokers, program administrators, and occasionally policyholders to better understand market needs.
  • Help bridge the gap between technical insurance product development and successful market execution.

Required Qualifications

  • Minimum of 5 years of small commercial insurance underwriting experience with an insurance carrier or Managing General Agent (MGA).
  • Direct, hands-on experience designing, developing, or enhancing small commercial insurance products.
  • Strong technical expertise in one or more commercial insurance lines, including Professional Liability, General Liability, BOP, Fiduciary Liability, Cyber, EPLI, Commercial Crime, or D&O / Management Liability.
  • Familiarity with other small commercial insurance products and coverage structures.
  • Strong understanding of insurance policy forms, endorsements, coverage language, and underwriting guidelines.
  • Proven ability to translate underwriting expertise and market opportunities into competitive, scalable insurance products.
  • Experience working across multiple departments to develop and launch insurance products.
  • Strong analytical skills with the ability to evaluate product profitability, loss performance, and market competitiveness.
  • Excellent communication, organizational, and problem-solving skills.
  • Proficiency with Microsoft Office and Google Workspace.

Preferred Qualifications

  • Experience developing bundled or packaged small commercial insurance products.
  • Familiarity with commercial surety bonds and their integration into insurance product offerings.
  • Experience working directly with agents, brokers, program administrators, and sales teams.
  • Demonstrated success introducing new products or expanding existing product lines.
  • Experience in a growing, entrepreneurial, or evolving insurance organization.
  • Strong understanding of insurance distribution and what makes products attractive to producers and customers.

What Makes Someone Successful in This Role?

We're looking for someone who combines technical insurance expertise with a practical, commercially focused approach to product development.

The ideal candidate:

  • Is hands-on: Has personally developed insurance products, coverage structures, forms, and underwriting guidelines rather than simply overseeing the process.
  • Thinks commercially: Understands what producers need to sell insurance products successfully while maintaining underwriting profitability.
  • Is innovative: Can identify opportunities to combine coverages into differentiated, marketable solutions.
  • Takes ownership: Can move projects from concept through execution without requiring extensive oversight.
  • Collaborates effectively: Works comfortably with underwriting, sales, technology, and senior leadership.
  • Understands the small commercial market: Recognizes the needs of small and mid-sized businesses and can translate those needs into practical insurance solutions.

Why Consider This Opportunity?

This is an opportunity to play an important role in the next phase of growth for an established national insurance carrier.

Rather than simply maintaining an existing portfolio, you will have the opportunity to help shape the company's commercial insurance product strategy, develop new offerings, and create bundled solutions that support long-term growth.

You will work closely with senior leadership and have meaningful involvement in decisions that influence the company's product development and market expansion.

If you're an experienced commercial insurance professional who enjoys building products, identifying market opportunities, and turning ideas into successful insurance solutions, we'd welcome the opportunity to speak with you.

 

JOB ID: 183788

#post

Warren Mead

To Apply for this Job Click Here

Share This Job

Share This Job

Remote Recruiter

Phoenix, Arizona
Sales
$100,000 to $200,000

Recruiter

Stamford, Connecticut
Sales
$100,000 to $200,000

Buyer / Procurement Specialist

Fort Lauderdale, Florida
Sales
$55,000 to $60,000

Regional Travel Industry Sales Manager

Boston, Massachusetts
Sales
$90,000 to $90,000

Additional Information

At Goodwin Recruiting, our clients seek qualified candidates, and that is what we deliver. A person’s age, gender, race, color, marital or family status, national origin, disability, religion, veteran status, sexual orientation, gender identity has no bearing on whether they are able to do the job. We evaluate the knowledge, skills, and abilities that meet the requirements of the position and aim to open doors and change lives. We work hard to identify a broad slate of candidates for each of our clients, with many hiring success stories to share.

Featured Image

Warren Mead

Senior Recruiting Partner